This past week I tried two of the more popular free online storage sites.
- ADrive, a smaller company, in business since 2007, that offers a generous 50gb of free disk space.
- Microsoft, whose SkyDrive service offers 25gb of free space to users of its free Live service.
I was disappointed in both of them.
The ADrive service made it easy enough to sign up. After answering a few questions, I received a confirmation e-mail in my inbox. One click later, I was able to sign in to ADrive. The user interface was pretty basic, but that's what I was looking for. I did not need any fancy bells and whistles. I simply wanted safe, off-site storage of my picture files.
Using ADrive was not quite as easy as signing up. Through the "basic" interface, it allowed me to specify and copy only one file at a time. I have thousands of pictures. One file at a time won't work. There is a more advanced interface, written in Java, that is supposed to allow you to drag and drop multiple files. Using my Google Chrome browser, the Java errored out and the drag and drop interface would not work. Still optimistic, I try using Internet Explorer to access the drag-and-drop Java functionality. No luck.
After about a half hour of playing around, trying different combinations, I lost interest.
ADrive does offer something they call the ADrive desktop client which sounds like it has a nice Windows based interface to upload and download files. Unfortunately, the desktop client is not included with the Basic (free) plan. At a minimum, the ADrive desktop client will run you $6.95 per month. Here is a snapshot of what you get with the ADrive free and pay plans.
Next up, Microsoft SkyDrive
The Microsoft SkyDrive offering is part of the Windows Live initiative. Windows Live is Mircrosofts answer to the myriad of online services that Google and Yahoo offer. Signing up for SkyDrive requires you to have a Windows Live (or Hotmail) account. I had one already, so signing up was a snap. Actually, signing up was not necessary. I simple signed into live.com and SkyDrive popped up as one of my available options.
Time to upload some files! I simply select a folder, click upload and... WTF! ...I am faced with a screen with 5 lines for names of files and 5 upload buttons. Yes, sports-fans, that's right, only 5 files can be uploaded at a time! There has to be a better way.
...and there was, sort of. After a lot of digging through online help, I uncovered a reference to an Active X component that I could download to drag-and-drop files into my SkyDrive. Cool!
Well, almost cool. First, I found that the Active X control was not available to me when I was running Google Chrome, so I had to fire up Internet Explorer. Second, once I installed the Active X control, I could not drag-and-drop a directory (folder). Only file-by-file. Bummer. I have hundreds of directories. I assumed drag-and-drop meant directories as well as files. Oh well.
All in all, I was quite disappointed in both services. For now, I will resort to the old standbys; external disk backup, DVD backup, or at a minimum, saving my most important pictures on Picassa.
I have heard rumors that Google will be offering a service called GDrive sometime in 2009. As has been the case with search, e-mail (gmail), or RSS Readers (Google Reader), Google will get it right where others have not. I think I'll wait out the rumors and hope for a GDrive solution.